You may have to pay back Workers’ Compensation in New York if you receive a third-party settlement, are overpaid benefits, or return to work while still collecting payments. While Workers’ Compensation is designed to cover medical bills and lost wages after a workplace injury, certain circumstances may require repayment to the Workers’ Compensation insurance company.
This process can be complex, and a New York Workers’ Compensation lawyer can help protect your financial interests by ensuring you only repay what is legally required. Understanding when and why repayment may be necessary can help you plan and avoid unexpected financial burdens. This article explains the key situations where repayment may be required, how repayment works, and what steps you can take to minimize its impact on your finances.
What is Workers’ Compensation?
Almost all employers in New York must carry Workers’ Compensation insurance coverage. This coverage provides benefits to workers who experience an on-the-job injury or illness. These Workers’ Compensation benefits are available on a no-fault basis and generally include:
- All medical expenses required to treat the injury or illness
- Weekly payments covering up to two-thirds of the injured worker’s average weekly wages
The New York Workers’ Compensation Board oversees this benefits program in New York.
When Do You have to Pay Back Workers’ Comp in New York?
While Workers’ Compensation payments typically do not require repayment, certain situations may obligate you to reimburse these benefits, such as:
Overpayment of Benefits
Workers’ Compensation overpayments occur when an injured worker receives more wage benefits than they are legally entitled to. This can happen due to miscalculated weekly wages or clerical errors, among other reasons. When this happens, insurers have the right to recover overpaid benefits, either by requesting direct repayment or reducing future benefits.
If you receive a notice of overpayment, review it carefully to ensure accuracy. You may be able to negotiate a repayment plan or dispute the claim if the overpayment was not your fault. Insurers may waive the repayment under specific circumstances.
Consulting a Workers’ Compensation attorney can help you determine your options and avoid financial hardship. Promptly addressing overpayments can prevent legal and financial consequences down the line.
Returning to Work While Receiving Benefits
In New York, returning to work while receiving Workers’ Compensation benefits requires careful adherence to reporting obligations to prevent overpayments. If you resume work, it’s imperative for you to inform the Workers’ Compensation insurance carrier immediately, as continued benefit payments after returning to work can result in overpayments and potentially fraud claims.
The New York State Comptroller’s Office explains that overpayments, whether due to administrative errors or unreported changes in employment status, are subject to recovery by the state.
To avoid financial and legal complications, maintain open communication with your employer and insurer regarding your work status. Prompt reporting ensures accurate benefit adjustments and prevents the accrual of overpayments that you may have to repay.
Third-Party Lawsuits
If a third party’s negligence (such as falling off a ladder) caused your work-related injury, you may file a personal injury lawsuit against that party in addition to receiving Workers’ Compensation benefits. According to New York Workers’ Compensation Law Section 29, the Workers’ Compensation insurance carrier holds a lien on any recovery from such third-party claims, allowing them to recoup benefits already paid to you.
In other words, if you secure a settlement or judgment from a third party, a portion of that amount may be used to reimburse the insurer for the Workers’ Compensation benefits you’ve received for the same losses. It’s essential to understand this potential repayment obligation when considering third-party legal action alongside your Workers’ Compensation claim.
Because these cases involve both Workers’ Compensation laws and personal injury claims, determining how much you may owe can be complicated. The third-party’s attorney will negotiate the repayment amount, ensure you keep as much of your settlement as possible, and guide you through the legal process to protect your financial interests.
Steps to Take if You Need to Repay Workers’ Comp in New York
If you must repay some of your Workers’ Compensation benefits in New York, you should first carefully review the repayment notice. Ensure that the amount requested is accurate by checking payment records and confirming the insurer’s calculations. Insurers may recover overpayments through deductions from future benefits or by requesting a direct repayment.
If repayment is required, you may be able to negotiate a payment plan in certain cases. A New York Workers’ Compensation lawyer can help you dispute an incorrect repayment claim and negotiate a settlement to minimize financial hardship.
Acting quickly is important, as ignoring repayment requests could lead to collection efforts. Seeking legal guidance can ensure you only repay what is necessary while protecting your financial well-being.
How a New York Workers’ Compensation Lawyer Can Help You
Handling a Workers’ Compensation repayment in New York can be complex, especially when dealing with overpayments or third-party settlements. Hiring a Workers’ Compensation lawyer can benefit you in several ways. First, they can ensure you only repay what is legally required and dispute incorrect repayment demands.
If you receive a repayment notice, an attorney can review the claim, check for errors, and negotiate on your behalf. In cases involving third-party settlements, they may be able to minimize your repayment obligations by applying legal deductions, such as attorney’s fees and court costs. If you face an overpayment dispute, they can assist in requesting waivers or structured repayment plans to ease the financial burden.
New York’s Workers’ Compensation laws are strict, but having legal representation ensures your rights are protected and helps you avoid unnecessary financial setbacks.
Why don’t you?Free Case Consultation
Let a New York Workers’ Compensation Attorney Help with Your Claim
Understanding your rights and obligations under New York Workers’ Compensation laws can help you avoid unexpected repayment and financial burdens.
If you receive a repayment notice, act quickly to review the claim, confirm its accuracy, and explore your options. In some cases, negotiating a repayment plan or disputing incorrect charges can reduce your financial liability. A New York Workers’ Compensation lawyer from O’Connor Law can help protect your rights, ensure fair repayment terms, and minimize unnecessary repayment obligations. Contact us today for a free case review.
